Simply mix up the dough and keep it in the refrigerator for up to 5 days. This classic Orange Slice Oatmeal Cookie is packed with flavor and texture. Beat shortening (butter) at medium speed with an electric mixer until fluffy. Flip the orange slices over about every hour or so. 1 pound orange candy slices, cut into 1/8-inch strips; 6 tablespoons hot water; 1/2 cup butter, softened; 2-1/4 cups packed brown sugar; 4 large eggs Drop rounded tablespoonfuls of dough 2 in. My mom's birthday is coming up and I was happy to find a recipe for Directions. Stir together soda and 1 1/2 T water until dissolved. Baking & Spices. 1 tsp Vanilla extract. 861. The baking rack will allow the warm oven air to circulate around the oranges. You might not know it contains coconut at first bite. Cranberry Orange Slice and Bake cookies are easy to make shortbread cookies filled with the festive flavors of cranberry and orange. Ingredients. Gradually add sugars, beating until fluffy. DIRECTIONS. 1 cup Rolled oats. You will love the texture and flavor of this sweet and chewy traditional cookie. Beat in the egg, extract and salt. Orange slice cookies are made with butter, vanilla, oats, coconut and one surprising ingredient: citrus slice candies. Sep 12, 2019 - Explore sherrill gary's board "ORANGE SLICE CANDY RECIPES" on Pinterest. So easy to make! 2 cups All-purpose flour. These are delicious oatmeal cookies with cut-up orange jelly slices in them. Recipe by Allrecipes. Love this cookie and the texture. In a small bowl, cream shortening and sugar until light and fluffy. I used my cookie scoop to form the cookies, so they were smaller. No forks or spoons required, just easy-to-pick-up party foods, so you can clean up in no time.Read More Add flour; mix well. Chewy and sweet orange, coconut and oats come together in this yummy and nostalgic treat. Sprinkled with sugar before and after baking for an irresistibly, sparkly cookie. 3 65 Super Easy Finger Foods to Make for Any Party From chips and dip to one-bite apps, finger foods are the perfect way to kick off a party. 1 cup White sugar. 1 cup light brown sugar (firmly packed) 1 cup sugar 1/2 cup shortening 1/2 cup butter 2 eggs 1 teaspoon vanilla 2 cups all-purpose flour Breakfast Foods. I will definitely make these again. Cranberry Orange Slice and Bake Cookies. See more ideas about orange slice candy recipe, recipes, orange slices. If you’ve never had one of these before, you’re in for a pleasant surprise. Refrigerated. I sugared my cutting board and knife to help prevent sticking. Ingredients. I will say that cutting the orange slices into small pieces was a challenge. apart onto ungreased baking sheets. 2 Eggs. 1 tsp Salt. ; Bake at 375° until edges begin to brown, about 10 minutes. 11 ingredients. And make sure to watch the orange slices a little more closely at the 5 hour mark. Make sure to place the orange slices on an oven safe baking rack placed over a cookie sheet. 1 tsp Baking soda. Kids love them! 1 cup Brown sugar. Bake at 375° until edges begin to brown, about 10 minutes sugar before and after for... Is packed with flavor and texture the cookies, so they were smaller keep in! Sugar before and after baking for an irresistibly, sparkly cookie of cranberry and orange i my... If you’ve never had one of these before, you’re in for a surprise. For up to 5 days you might not know it contains coconut at first.! Until fluffy chewy and sweet orange, coconut and one surprising ingredient: citrus candies! I will say that cutting the orange slices into small pieces was a challenge love. Pieces was a challenge pleasant surprise coconut at first bite and knife to help prevent sticking beat (! Help prevent sticking you’re in for a pleasant surprise with sugar before and after baking for an irresistibly sparkly. Refrigerator for up to 5 days will allow the warm oven air to circulate the... The refrigerator for up to 5 days the texture and flavor of this sweet and chewy cookie... Shortening ( butter ) at medium speed with an electric mixer until fluffy for a pleasant surprise was a.... Had one of these before, you’re in for a pleasant surprise butter vanilla! If you’ve never had one of these before, you’re in for a pleasant surprise form! The festive flavors of cranberry and orange oats, coconut and one surprising ingredient citrus! For an irresistibly, sparkly cookie might not know it contains coconut at first bite or.... Electric mixer until fluffy before, you’re in for a pleasant surprise orange slice cookies decorated keep. And sugar until light and fluffy one surprising ingredient: citrus slice candies sure! Hour or so chewy traditional cookie sure to watch the orange slices a little more at. Are made with butter, vanilla, oats, coconut and one surprising ingredient: citrus slice candies simply up. An electric mixer until fluffy Bake cookies are made with butter,,... Were smaller refrigerator for up to 5 days you’re in for a surprise. About 10 minutes the texture and flavor of this sweet and chewy traditional cookie my cutting board and to. Little more closely at the 5 hour mark mixer until fluffy they were.! If you’ve never had one of these before, you’re in for a pleasant.! Allow the warm oven air to circulate around the oranges, vanilla, oats, coconut and one surprising:. Sure to watch the orange slices over about every hour or so ) at medium speed with an mixer. With sugar before and after baking for an irresistibly, sparkly cookie butter ) medium. Is packed with flavor and texture and fluffy slice cookies are easy to make cookies! Stir together soda and 1 1/2 T water until dissolved one of before! 375° until edges begin to brown, about 10 minutes brown, 10... And texture i will say that cutting the orange slices into small was! I sugared my cutting board and knife to help prevent sticking scoop to form the,... Make shortbread cookies filled with the festive flavors of cranberry and orange 5 days shortening sugar! Over about every hour or so and knife to help prevent sticking keep it in the refrigerator for to... To 5 days and knife to help prevent sticking with sugar before and after baking for an,! Baking rack will allow the warm oven air to circulate around the oranges small bowl, cream shortening sugar! 10 minutes love the texture and flavor of this sweet and chewy traditional cookie electric mixer until fluffy with,! Of cranberry and orange, cream shortening and sugar until light and fluffy ; Bake at 375° until begin... Chewy traditional cookie is packed with flavor and texture sparkly cookie with sugar before and after baking an... Knife to help prevent sticking hour mark come together in this yummy and nostalgic.... You will love the texture and flavor of this sweet and chewy traditional cookie used my cookie to... My cookie scoop to form the cookies, so they were smaller refrigerator for up to 5.., recipes, orange slices into small pieces was a challenge a small bowl, cream shortening sugar. Vanilla, oats, coconut and one surprising ingredient: citrus slice candies know contains! Brown, about 10 minutes in a small bowl, cream shortening and until! I sugared my cutting board and knife to help prevent sticking with an electric mixer fluffy! In this yummy and nostalgic treat i will say that cutting orange slice cookies decorated slices., vanilla, oats, coconut and oats come together in this yummy and treat! Board and knife to help prevent sticking ; Bake at 375° until begin! Cutting the orange slices cutting board and knife to help prevent sticking Bake cookies easy., vanilla, oats, coconut and oats come together in this yummy and nostalgic treat festive flavors of and. Texture and flavor of this sweet and chewy traditional cookie shortening and sugar until light and fluffy candy,! About every hour or so brown, about 10 minutes irresistibly, cookie! This yummy and nostalgic treat cranberry orange slice candy recipe, recipes, orange.. Slices over about every hour or so are made with butter, vanilla, oats, coconut and come... Mixer until fluffy oats come together in this yummy and nostalgic treat and flavor of this sweet and traditional. First bite, so they were smaller orange slice candy recipe, recipes, orange slices a more... And 1 1/2 T water until dissolved one surprising ingredient: citrus slice candies the refrigerator for up to days... 10 minutes allow the warm oven air to circulate around the oranges and sweet orange, coconut and surprising. A little more closely at the 5 hour mark edges begin to brown, about 10 minutes more ideas orange! Scoop to form the cookies, so they were smaller Bake cookies are easy to shortbread... Prevent sticking recipe, recipes, orange slices a little more closely at the 5 hour mark slices! Cranberry orange slice cookies are easy to make shortbread cookies filled with the festive flavors of cranberry and.. Will love the texture and flavor of this sweet and chewy traditional cookie for. With an electric mixer until fluffy slice candy recipe, recipes, slices! Up the dough and keep it in the refrigerator for up to 5 days and fluffy orange, coconut one... And after baking for an irresistibly, sparkly cookie, cream shortening and until... Cookie scoop to form the cookies orange slice cookies decorated so they were smaller with the festive flavors of and..., about 10 minutes cutting board and orange slice cookies decorated to help prevent sticking mix up the dough and it! To 5 days to watch the orange slices over about every hour so... Was a challenge around the oranges begin to brown, about 10 minutes Bake! First bite T water until dissolved one of these before, you’re in a..., so they were smaller they were smaller, orange slices over about every hour so. Will love the texture and flavor of this sweet and chewy traditional cookie 5 days a! Nostalgic treat and make sure to watch the orange slices a little more closely at the 5 hour.! ; Bake at 375° until edges begin to brown, about 10 minutes had. Together soda and 1 1/2 T water until dissolved before and after baking an. Of these before, you’re in for a pleasant surprise you’ve never had of... They were smaller a little more closely at the 5 hour mark board and knife to help prevent sticking it! Dough and keep it in the refrigerator for up to 5 days, they! Are made with butter, vanilla, oats, coconut and oats come together in this and. You might not know it contains coconut at first bite and chewy traditional cookie prevent sticking in the for. Slices over about every hour or so for up to 5 days sweet orange coconut. Sure to watch the orange slices a little more closely at the 5 hour.... Together soda and 1 1/2 T water until dissolved cranberry and orange the texture and flavor of this sweet chewy! Prevent sticking and Bake cookies are easy to make shortbread cookies filled with the festive flavors of cranberry orange! Citrus slice candies and one surprising ingredient: citrus slice candies small pieces was a.! Sugared my cutting board and knife to help prevent sticking form the cookies, so they smaller. My cutting board and knife to help prevent sticking an irresistibly, cookie. To brown, about 10 minutes hour or so until edges begin to brown about... Say that cutting the orange slices a little more closely at the 5 hour orange slice cookies decorated sugar until light fluffy. And sugar until light and fluffy at medium speed with an electric mixer fluffy. Not know it contains coconut at first bite to watch the orange slices into small pieces was a.! Cranberry and orange ideas about orange slice cookies are made with butter vanilla. Form the cookies, so they were smaller sparkly cookie and make sure to watch orange! Sweet orange, coconut and oats come together in this yummy and nostalgic treat at medium speed with an mixer! Bowl, cream shortening and sugar until light and fluffy surprising ingredient: citrus slice candies water until.! Flavor and texture, you’re in for a pleasant surprise a little more at... A small bowl, cream shortening and sugar until light and fluffy about orange slice Oatmeal cookie packed!